Comparative case study method. The Use of Qualitative Content Analysis in Case Study Research 2019-01-17

Comparative case study method Rating: 5,9/10 1819 reviews

case selection and the comparative method: introducing the case selector

comparative case study method

Yet others see the same institutional setting as a prescription for more aggressive behavior. What is the causal relationship between crisis, learning and change? In fact, a theory or theoretical framework first emerges through the inductive approach of studying an empirical case or object, not through a deductive process. He contended that the quantitative orientation neglected the particular quality of texts and that it was important to reconstruct contexts. Fieldwork is suitable, as the intention of the research was to reveal emerging processes as they occurred in the field Hammersley and Atkinson 2007. Predictive validity can only be used as a quality criterion if predictions can reasonably be made from the material in this case verification is usually easy and significant. On second level, triangulation takes place by applying a method of analysis qualitative content analysis that has not been particularly developed for this purpose to a different research design case study research. Besides, the analyzing of data is enhanced by reference to the existing literature and using this to raise questions about whether the researcher's findings are consistent with or different from extant research ibid.

Next

Comparative Case Studies: Methodological Briefs

comparative case study method

. Or, put more generally: What is the contribution of using qualitative content analysis as an interpretation and analysis method for developing case studies? He further theorized from this that decommodification was based on a combination of class coalitions and mobilization, and regime legacy. Therefore, it can be argued that qualitative content analysis could prove to be a useful tool for analyzing data material in case study research. Engagement varies between and within communities and over time. Phase 3 involved analysis of Charity Commission data on voluntary support.

Next

The Use of Qualitative Content Analysis in Case Study Research

comparative case study method

In fact, it is not only the manifest content of the material that is important but also the latent content as well as formal aspects need to be taken into consideration cf. However, going into greater detail concerning these issues would be beyond the scope of this paper. In this light I have chosen a case study approach using an empirical inquiry of real-world phenomena within its naturally occurring context Kaarbo andBeasley 1999, Yin 2009. The creation of knowledge through case study research. We find that previous research is limited theoretically by confounding institutional effects with policy positions, and empirically by analyzing only international conflict data. The research questions have been investigated with a qualitative and interpretative approach which allows researchers to emphasize the context within which the activities studied occur and their meanings for participants Bresler and Stake 2002.

Next

Comparative Case Study

comparative case study method

This article concludes that psychological approaches can bring an added value by allowing for a better illustration of decision-making processes. Kennedy, during the Cuban missile crisis, is examined in detail to demonstrate the way in which feelings of shame and humiliation are frequently followed by narcissistic rage that expresses itself in acts of aggression in an attempt to alleviate those painful affects and increase feelings of self-worth. In accordance with these requirements, a direct claim for generalization without a mention of other cases that support the same finding under similar contexts , cannot be considered as appropriate. The assessment allows an understanding of the governance context and is paired with a comparative case study design. Your objects are specimens or cases which are similar in some respects otherwise, it would not be meaningful to compare them but they differ in some respects. Social research methods 2nd ed. This is again in order to achieve a holistic and comprehensive analysis of complex social phenomena.

Next

SAGE Reference

comparative case study method

In both rounds, the high-consensus threshold was set at 70% agreement among respondents for each item. Two key factors are space and time. The first stage is the determination of the units of analysis, after which the dimensions of the structuring are established on some theoretical basis and the features of the system of categories are fixed. This is the normative question on which we focus from the outset in order to solve the theoretical puzzle. Provide advice on possible criteria for matching.


Next

A Practical Guide to the Comparative Case Study Method

comparative case study method

The final goal of research is usually to reveal the systematic structure, , that is true not only for the cases that were studied, but for the entire group where the cases came from. Here the text can be structured according to content, form and scaling. A Handbook of Comparative Social Policy. Copyright c 2006 Florian Kohlbacher This work is licensed under a. It also offers suggestions for future study of more contingent and multilinear models of foreign policy processes in comparative perspective. Furthermore, misconceptions about case studies contribute to the methodological barrier that exists within and between the two parent disciplines.

Next

Case Study Methods

comparative case study method

It highlights the limited nature of impact evidence available in all instances, which restricts our ability to properly evaluate the effect of new school types on outcomes. The goal is to find out why the cases are different: to reveal the general underlying structure which generates or allows such a variation. This study is generally aggregate data analysis. We test this argument using a global events data set incorporating foreign policy behaviors of numerous multiparty and single-party governments. Accuracy Semantic validity relates to the meaning reconstruction of the material, and is expressed in the appropriateness of the category definitions, the key examples and the rules for coders. They briefly outline broad requirements for rigorous and consistent reporting without constraining methodological freedom.


Next

UNICEF Webinar 6: Comparative Case Studies

comparative case study method

We then run our exercise in causal identification through a plausibility probe. Providing only an introduction to the theoretical argument, the need for further theoretical discussion as well as the empirical testing of the argument is obvious. Reading achievement of South African children is not on par with world standards and is a matter of great concern for parents, teachers and the educational authorities. These practices transform the world. As we have seen in Section 3. By interviewing 45 journalists, journalism educators, funders, and evaluators across six countries, as well as examining primary source documents, I show that although emerging from radically different contexts, the Saami and Roma are both distinct nations stretching over two or more states—transnational—which allows, and indeed requires, a unique approach to journalism. Therefore, qualitative content analysis offers a rule-based, theory-guided method for analyzing interview transcripts, just in the way it is required by the principles of case study research.


Next

A Practical Guide to the Comparative Case Study Method

comparative case study method

Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology 2nd ed. Employing theory from security studies and political psychology as well as a combination of quantitative cross-national analyses and twelve qualitative comparative case studies of foreign policy made by coalition cabinets in Japan, the Netherlands, and Turkey, Kaarbo identifies the factors that generate highly aggressive policies, inconsistency, and other policy outcomes. This technique often utilizes multiple disciplines in one study. It is a useful approach to document stories of impact and to develop an understanding of the factors that enhance or impede impact. Today audiences can select content that is consonant with their political notions, and they take advantage of this opportunity. Das Potential einer variablenorientierten qualitativen Inhaltsanalyse. The method is also versatile: you can use it in detail work as a complement to other methods, or the entire structure of a research project can consist of the comparison of just a few cases.

Next