General haig quotes. Did General Haig deserve to be the Butcher of the Somme? 2019-01-10
General haig quotes Rating:
7,3/10
745
reviews
Alexander Haig
I don't know which of us was the most glad to be rid of the other. The Machine Gun Corps, though comparatively recently formed, has done very valuable work and will increase in importance. What greater honor could come to an American, and a soldier? To have refused to fight then and there would have meant the abandonment of Verdun to its fate and the breakdown of the co-operation with the French. His outdated tactics led to the war being even more prolonged and unintentionally prevented a victory over the Germans. As to whether it were wise or foolish to give battle on the Somme on the first of July, 1916, there can surely be only one opinion. This source was written in 1998.
At he led an active sporting and social life but left without taking a degree. Haig became responsibe for training the Indian Cavalry. Therefore, he was unaware to the tactics. They were too weak to drive the enemy entirely off the ground it had conquered in 1914, so the Germans believed they had never in fact been defeated. My leg had shrunk a bit and I was given a pension of twenty-five shillings per week for six months. However, he changed his mind and decided to launch the. Any comments that can help me get to grips with his character would be appreciated! On the other hand, the second interpretation is that Haig was just doing his job as a general.
Did General Haig deserve to be the Butcher of the Somme?
And another story of how he visited some young officers doing a tactical course: he said he had little time to spare and could not go into the detail of the tactical scheme which they were studying, but would give them some general advice based on his own experience of war. However, this might not be such reliable as the other evidences. These to be prepared by intense artillery and trench-mortar bombardments. Haig's one-step breakthrough attempt was the antithesis of Robertson's cautious approach of exhausting the enemy with artillery and limited advances. Some of it was never cleared out to the end of the War. Haig evidently believed that will and resolve could carry any obstacle.
There exists no yardstick for the measurement of such events, there are no returns to prove whether life has been sold at its market value. With 20,000 Allied soldiers killed on Day One and 40,000 injured, some historians have claimed that Haig should have learned from these statistics and adjusted his tactics. Haig actively promoted the methods and technologies that eventually helped break the deadlock—new tactics, machine guns, effective training, airpower, artillery, tanks and the like. Haig later earned a Master of Business Administration degree from Columbia Business School in 1955 and a Master of Arts degree in international relations from Georgetown University in 1961. The new prime minister, Lloyd George, wanted to fight defensively on the Western Front while waiting for the Americans, now in the war, to begin arriving in Europe in decisive numbers. In fact, they would never have been surprised if he used bombardments of artillery every time before he attacked!. He still had his defenders, but they were in the last trench, barely holding on.
Alexander Haig Quotes, Famous Quotes by Alexander Haig
Let them not be despondent and think that the day of the horse was over. He tried his best and put a lot of effort on the planning and war, so that Britain had its victory at last. Haig believed that the Germans were close to the point of exhaustion and continued to order further attacks expected each one to achieve the necessary breakthrough. There are some who give him credit for managing the resources of the British and Colonial armies in such a way that made victory possible. But history had always shown that great inventions somehow or other cured themselves; they always produced antidotes, and he believed that the value of the horse and the opportunity for the horse in the future were likely to be as great as ever. General Military History of all ages the quote of haig and the wire and artillery taken quiet literally is probably true if he did say this as quoted.
Though one of the intelligence officer's duties may be to help maintain his commander's morale, Charteris crossed the frontier between optimism and delusion. Obviously, it's more fun when you win. Still, at the other extreme, one can argue persuasively that Haig did not merely fail to achieve his stated objectives in the great battles of the Somme and Ypres. The Great War 100 app tells the story of the First World War using infographics. Arguably, this is a reliable source, as it is claimed to come directly from Haig's war-time diary. These principles served as a bond between Robertson and Haig when the two men dominated British military policy. Lieutenant discovered captured documents that three German divisions from the Russian front had arrived to strengthen the Cambrai sector.
But if Haig had ever heard of Cold Harbor, he plainly did not believe its lessons applied to British soldiers. Telescope observation from our own lines would again only give a limited view, and no sense of depth for the entanglements. Haig had to change their plans as the Germans were fighting the French. Ice Hockey Rugby- Union of course! These were not orders that could be given lightly and if they were, then the weight of evidence against Haig: The Educated Soldier, increases. Tim Tim, I agree with everything you say. Defence : 'Douglas Haig was a brave and intelligent man, for he was educated at Oxford University and later attended Sand Hurst Military School.
The higher staffs were out of touch with the regimental officers and with the troops. He was called 'The Butcher of the Somme'. Employing 476 tanks, six infantry and two cavalry divisions, the British Third Army gained over 6km in the first day. In 1906 Halsane created the Imperial General Staff under the leadership of Haig. They were stuck with him. He acted on this view, and, at the last, he was right, though it is open to argument not only that victory could have been won sooner elsewhere but that Haig's method of winning it was clumsy, tragically expensive of life, and based for too long on a misreading of the facts.
