Discussion Conclusions and Recommendation 1. Unfortunately this is not always the case. Are recommendations for future action made? This title utilised by Glacken and Chaney is concise, consisting of 13 words in bold print. It was difficult to identify the exact research question, as there was no definite question asked. The literature indicates that complementary medicine practitioners are moving away from traditional knowledge and towards the use of evidence based practice in their clinical discussions. Need to factor out the experience variable.
In addition, the pay scale was adjusted upwards across nursing. Is each result discussed in terms of the original hypothesis to which it relates? However, this is referred to in the Implications and Recommendations section. On the next page center the title of your work and start providing necessary details, not forgetting to double space the text. It does not clearly indicate the research approach used Cormack, 2000. However, you should address highlighted questions. Keywords Three to six keywords that encapsulate the main topics of the research will have been drawn from the body of the article. The authors begin by discussing.
If you follow all the recommendations, you will easily complete an outstanding article critique without any efforts! The results have addressed the aims of the study and are both informative and descriptive. The researchers qualification and credentials in the article are clearly stated and easy to find. In the summary section, you should write a brief up to 500 words summary of the article in your own words. The researchers do not state how they minimised this Hawthorne Effect. This would suggest that they have the research skills and expertise to carry out such a study. Is background information on the problem presented? Strengths and weaknesses of for the Research Article Critique study This study revealed several strengths.
Although the title still provides insight into what the article is trying to accomplish. Another element of the research critique involves the sample. You need to give the reader an idea of whether the author of an article based it on facts and credible information. Valente 2003 believes that under this section the researchers should summarise their major findings and conclude their application to practice, research, and theory and knowledge development. They all work within nursing education within a University context. There is no indication who administered the questionnaires, whether or not they were self-report in the participants own time and convenience, or whether a researcher was present at the time of completion. In South Africa, there appears to be poor understanding about using a systematic review as an acceptable research method in post-graduate nursing education.
This could be considered a limitation in the reporting of this research. Part of this process of providing care based on the best available evidence involves appraising primary research Elliott, 2001, p 555. From reading the reference list, it can be seen that this is the case and only three references before 1994 have been used. Help Here is a hint on how to evaluate an article. The author of this critique believes the research problem is in the last sentence of the introduction.
According to Russell 2004 if a descriptive design was used the reader should find descriptive statistics such as mean, mode, median and standard deviation. Conceptual Underpinnings and Research Questions The framework used is made explicit and has been adapted by a previous theorist. But for many qualified and student nurses, the terminology used in research can be difficult to understand, thus making critical reading even more daunting. Here are some links which may be of benefit to you:. The instructor said this presentation would have made a 100 if I hadn't have put the wrong type of study. Discussion The discussion appears quite balanced Cormack, 2000 , and is very detailed, which is good, given the complexity of this study, involving as it does multiple data collection instruments.
Is the design appropriate for answering the questions or testing the hypotheses of the study? The current approach to evidence based practice in healthcare adds a third component which is patient values. · Is the research important? Operational definitions Cormack 2000 suggests that people appraising research question whether operational definitions are clearly presented. According to Polit and Beck 2004 the aim of critically appraising an article is an attempt to determine its strengths and limitations. Author Sarah Vogel specialises in producing well researched articles in the field of health and medicine. Are the tests of significance interpreted using the appropriate degrees of freedom? That is, can it be investigated through the collection and analysis of data? The purpose of the research was to determine whether leg-crossing impacted the results of blood pressure measurements.
This title includes all… 1663 Words 7 Pages Control is and has been a pervasive factor in the lives of many across the world, influencing the way research can be conducted or the way people try to maintain a balance in the weight or appearance. Journal Clubs are a well-recognized strategy used by clinicians to critique and keep up to date with relevant literature. If nurses are to improve their practice, and apply evidence to improve their clinical and theoretical knowledge and skills, they must be able to assess the quality of the available research which is relevant to their practice Freshwater and Bishop, 2003k p23; Hek, 2000, p 19. Introduction The purpose of the introductory section is to clearly identify the problem and give a rationale for the study been carried out Cormack 2000. In the critique section, you evaluate the article using the following grading criteria.
Executive summary: Final report of the Task Force on the North Carolina Nursing Workforce. The research was designed to address the recurring nursing shortages coupled with the quality of contemporary health care and the need to recruit and retain a framework of professional nurses in hospitals. The study relates the findings back to a wide range of other research studies, which is a strength of this part of the report, showing congruence with many other findings in relation to quality of life, age, socioeconomic status, social support, antiretroviral treatment, symptoms, and self-care Tangkawanich et al, 2008 p 219. Many students fail to complete this task, as they simply provide a summary of the analyzed paper, forgetting about personal approach and challenging your own skills and knowledge. It is imperative in nursing that care has its foundations in sound research, and it is essential that all nurses have the ability to critically appraise research to identify what is best practice. This is to help researcher to understand what is already known about a topic.